Susie Dent’s Death Writ Large – Dent strikes again!

Susie Dent’s Death Writ Large is a new dimension in the Clarendon saga. This is a direct follow-up to Guilty by Definition, set a couple of years after that book.

I reviewed Guilty by Definition on Digital Journal.com about this time in 2024. This was her first fiction novel, and she has some exceptional skills in this field that she may not have known she had. It’s an interesting and complex book, way ahead of mainstream whodunits for depth and quality.

I was a bit surprised that she’d found a publisher for such a demanding storyline. Generally, publishers tend to do the “For Dummies” stuff rather than anything worth reading.

Typical mainstream publishers would have said that the plot was too difficult. Zaffre, thank god, didn’t. They helped. The new book is a sort of vindication for Susie and Zaffre for a good idea.

Death Writ Large is Guilty by Definition on steroids. It’s 400 pages of solid storyline. There’s a very strong plot and a lot of people evolving in their own roles.

A necessary comment or so:

This book couldn’t be more English if it came with a Brigade of Guards band and a cup of good tea.

This is modern English culture; confrontational, awkward, intrusive, opaque, and decidedly difficult.

Susie does a much better job of describing her beloved Oxford than most videos. I took a Google street walk around some of the locations, and it really is fascinating.

Susie isn’t turning Oxford into a sort of Cotswaldian Midsomer. Quite the opposite; the story of Death Writ Large is highly intrusive on the setting and the people who’ve already had one severe shock in Guilty by Definition.

Martha Thornhill, who Susie says is her, arrives at the scene of a fatality to see the runes of fantasy writer John Naylor emblazoned nearby. She’d recently given a talk on fantasy writers including Naylor and could translate the runes.

She informs the police, in the form of her local detective Oliver Caldwell, or the meaning of the runes. It turns out that Naylor is something of a cult figure, and that a “cabal” of fans is well-known and much disliked by fellow Oxford alumni for their superior pretensions and arrogance.  

The senior police think it’s a suicide, but Caldwell isn’t so sure. Nor are the Clarendon team, who’ve had time to process the information and lack of information.

This is where the story starts, and it gets far more complex and downright nasty soon enough. There are clashing personalities, old grievances, and some difficult logic to deal with. The motive isn’t clear. Nobody knows what all this is trying to achieve.

Making things considerably more difficult is that whoever’s posting these large runes all over the place is tricky. The incidents are well planned. Clues are non-existent.

A new dimension in characters, particularly Martha’s emerges from the storm of problems created by the runes. Some very interesting writing and very competent character development is built into the storyline.

Susie is a much better and far more agile writer than she seems to think. In the acknowledgements, she credits everyone but herself for the book’s existence. This is no trivial gluing together of words. It’s much deeper.

She also manages to fit in some “in-quips” which will be instantly recognizable to Countdown/Catsdown fans. In a couple of paragraphs with not a blink of missing a beat. The dry wit is very welcome as the story reaches its terrifying climax.

I almost forgot to mention there’s some good lexi-stuff too, like Old English in the chapter headings, one of which means “patience weary”. You have to wonder what the Old English were up to.

Review status: 5 stars. If you read Guilty by Definition, you’ll like it. If you’re a Susie Dent fan, you’ll be glad to know that our rampaging lexi-deity is having fun writing.